Heathrow runway air quality sits on a wing and a prayer

 

There is, as has been pointed out, a lot of new ‘evidence’ that has caused ministers to re-open their consultation on plans for a new runway at Heathrow and it will all take a while to get to the bottom of.

One issue of central importance not just to aviation but to the transport sector and local authorities in general is air quality, so that’s a good place to try to unpick what is going on.

To get the clichés in early, the Government’s new, and already much-derided, national Air Quality Plan is a double-edged sword in relation to attempts to build a new runway, while the latest assessment of what a third Heathrow runway will do to air quality might be described as glass-half-empty dressed up as glass-half-full. 

In fact, the new Air Quality Plan (the ‘2017 Plan’) is what makes two adjacent but seemingly contradictory statements compatible. It just depends how you look at it:

1.3.1 The overall conclusion of the study is that, with the effective implementation of the Government’s 2017 Plan measures (as represented by the PCM model projections in the 2017 Plan), increased airport capacity will not affect modelled compliance with EU limit values. This applies whichever option is in operation…

1.3.2 Taking into account the inherent uncertainties in air quality modelling there remains, however, a risk that the options could delay or worsen compliance with limit values, albeit decreasing over time. […] for Heathrow [North West runway] the risk is high (again until 2030 when the risk drops to medium).

”Local
What a new terminal might look like

To translate: if everything is as we expect, things should be ok, but we can’t be at all sure.

The first statement depends heavily on ministers’ new plan – as implemented by London mayor Sadiq Khan – working, while the second adds the further qualification that it’s still pretty uncertain.

The test that the (2012-15) Airports Commission applied was whether a new runway would make the UK non compliant with EU limit values – an approach that was widely criticised. The Commission pointed out that all the time the UK somewhere (i.e. elsewhere in London) is projected to be non-compliant, a new runway at Heathrow would not make us non-compliant.

The new assessment asks whether a runway option would make a zone (i.e. London) newly non-compliant, whether it would delay compliance, and whether it would make pollution worse in some areas within a zone, albeit still lower than an exceedance elsewhere in the zone. All of these represent a potential fail for an option.

The double-edged sword that leads to the risk of a fail, at least on the last two tests, is that what is going on elsewhere on the roads is making things better.

1.3.5 Both Heathrow options increase pollutant concentrations on roads across London, including the roads giving the highest concentrations in the Greater London zone in the PCM modelling. Whilst this increase is small in magnitude, the opening of any option between 2026 and 2030 is coincident with the period over which the Greater London zone moves from non-compliance to compliance in the PCM model projections. As such, concentrations alongside some roads in central London, including the key A40 Westway, sit at or close to the limit value in all years and emissions scenarios and the small impact from airport expansion risks worsening exceedances of limit values on some routes or delaying compliance with limit values.

A new Heathrow North West runway could well open in the middle of the next decade and could well generate an increase in flights very quickly. But if plans for low emission and zero emission zones work, it should all be fine. ‘Should’ again being the operative word.

All in all, it’s a pretty arbitrary way to look at it – not just because the Government is applying rules that it will not necessarily be bound by after Britain leaves the EU but because it is so difficult to predict so far ahead how close we will be to breaking those rules, even without the new runway.

5.3.4 The critical link in all years is the A40 (Westway, 70181) in central London – over 15 km away from the airport boundary. On this road, the impact of the airport is small and the risk of noncompliance is determined to a large degree by the magnitude of the PCM model projection rather than the magnitude of the airport impact. On the critical link, the impact of the airport is small and related entirely to highway trips to the airport. The impact of airside emissions on the link, and on the compliance risks for the option overall, is negligible.

As this implies, and this makes the assessment even more arbitrary, there are even worse impacts at other places in London – i.e. on the A4 near Heathrow, where the impact is five times as high – but these negative impacts are discounted because the projected levels of pollution with and without the extra runway duck under the current limit, while nevertheless being harmful to human health.

Will a new runway at Heathrow make air pollution worse? Undoubtedly. Is this impact enough for it not to be built? You decide.

 

Also see

Register now for full access


Register just once to get unrestricted, real-time coverage of the issues and challenges facing UK transport and highways engineers.

Full website content includes the latest news, exclusive commentary from leading industry figures and detailed topical analysis of the highways, transportation, environment and place-shaping sectors. Use the link below to register your details for full, free access.

Already a registered? Login

 
comments powered by Disqus
 
 
highways jobs

Head of Economic Development & Regeneration

North Worcestershire
£65k (more may be available depending on skills & experience)
Our vision for North Worcestershire is that it will be a destination of choice for employers Worcestershire
Recuriter: North Worcestershire

TRANSPORT FOR WALES APPOINTMENT OF NON-EXECUTIVE CHAIR

Transport for Wales
£425.00 per day
Transport for Wales (TfW) is a not for profit company, wholly-owned by the Welsh Government and established in 2015. Wales
Recuriter: Transport for Wales

Fire Safety Contract Manager

Camden London Borough Council
£40,028 to £46,431
We are currently seeking an experienced Fire Safety Contract Manager to lead and co-ordinate activities and to ensure that the service is managed Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Pest Control Officer

Camden London Borough Council
£27,093 to £29,188
As a Pest Control Officer within Environmental Health, Business and Consumer Services your focus will be to deliver pest control treatments Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Senior Waste Prevention Officer

Camden London Borough Council
£35,913 - £41,657
We now have an exciting opportunity for a talented and enthusiastic individual to join us and be part of a team tottenham
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Senior Waste Prevention Officer

Camden London Borough Council
£35,913 - £41,657
We now have an exciting opportunity for a talented and enthusiastic individual to join us and be part of a team developing a new vision Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Operations Manager – Waste and Recycling

Bath & North East Somerset Council
£38,052- £40,858.
This is an exciting opportunity for an experienced waste management professional Bath, Somerset
Recuriter: Bath & North East Somerset Council

HGV Driver/Loader

Torridge District Council
£18,070 - £20,138
DRIVER/LOADER (HGV) Driving and loading a refuse/recycling collection vehicle up to 26 tonne gross weight, you will collect recycling or household ... Bideford, Devon
Recuriter: Torridge District Council

Principal Transport Officer

Cambridgeshire County Council
£37,320 to £40,198
The role will require close dialogue with developers and their agents and necessitate strong partnership working with District Councils... Cambridge, Cambridgeshire
Recuriter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Senior Engineer – Traffic and Road Safety

Redbridge London Borough Council
£35,992 - £38,994 per annum
Redbridge Council is an outer Borough, working to improve the environment and its services for residents and businesses. Redbridge, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Trainee Technician – Active and Sustainable Travel

Redbridge London Borough Council
£20,667 - £22,424 per annum
Redbridge Council is an outer Borough, working to improve the environment and its services for residents and businesses. Redbridge, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Senior Engineer – Parking

Redbridge London Borough Council
£35,992 - £38,994 per annum
To be responsible for the delivery of parking engineering design and implementation of schemes across the borough Ilford, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Senior Engineer – Highway Maintenance/Asset Management

Redbridge London Borough Council
£35,992 - £38,994 per annum
To be responsible for highway asset management, reactive and planned highway maintenance, highway safety and structural surveys and inspections. Ilford, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Trainee Technician – Projects

Redbridge London Borough Council
£20,667 - £22,424 per annum
Redbridge Council is an outer Borough, working to improve the environment and its services for residents and businesses. Redbridge, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Senior Engineer – Flood Management/Civil Engineering

Redbridge London Borough Council
£35,992 - £38,994 per annum
To provide expert advice on highway and land drainage, flood risk management, sustainable drainage, highway structures and bridges... Ilford, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Senior Engineer – Development Control

Redbridge London Borough Council
£35,992 - £38,994 per annum
To be responsible for assisting and supporting the operational delivery of the Council’s highways development control function and to assist the lead Ilford, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Engineer – Projects

Redbridge London Borough Council
£30,930 - £32,638 per annum
To assist with the delivery of highway and land drainage, flood risk management, sustainable drainage, highway structures and bridges... Ilford, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Engineer – Parking

Redbridge London Borough Council
£30,930 - £32,638 per annum
To assist with the delivery of parking engineering design and implementation of schemes across the borough Ilford, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Redbridge London Borough Council

Engineer (Bridges)

Cambridgeshire County Council
£32,825 - £35,401
You will have experience in the development, planning, design and implementation of transport infrastructure and related projects Cambridgeshire
Recuriter: Cambridgeshire County Council

Pest Control Officer

Brent Council
£25,746 - £27,342 p.a. inc.
Salary range
Recuriter: Brent Council