When will motorways be truly smart?


All lane running smart motorways are very much in the news, with the focus on how safe they are and how effectively Highways England is closing lanes to protect drivers stopped in live lanes that were previously the hard shoulder.

At the recent bank holiday weekend, I had my own – thankfully mainly vicarious – experience, which was already ringing alarm bells, so to speak, before the AA highlighted its own research into the issue.

Just before 11 on the Saturday morning, I was driving with a passenger up the M1 to Leeds. Towards the end of the journey, on an all lane running section of the motorway just south of the M62, I noticed that vehicles in the inside running lane were pulling out to avoid a van, which seemed to be half on and half off the carriageway.

I had seen no warning of this – no red Xs closing the inside lane.

Most all lane running schemes rely on cctv

Having written for Highways magazine about the vulnerability of vehicles stopped in live lanes, I was aware of the danger. I’ve also been to a few talks where Highways England chief executive Jim O’Sullivan exhorts his audience to put the company’s number - 0300 123 5000 – into their phones, so it is in mine.

I asked my passenger to use my phone to call Highways England. They were reluctant but agreed to do so when I said it could save someone’s life. After a short delay, they told Highways England of the vehicle in the live lane. Again, they didn’t seem to be aware of it at the time.

Highways England subsequently told me that its regional control room confirmed that signals were set once the police alerted them to the incident, which was at 10.55am. My call was at 10.53am so the two were more or less simultaneous.

The government-owned company also suggested that the best thing to do for someone witnessing an incident is the same as for a dangerously stranded driver – to dial 999 – but its online guidance on how to drive on a smart motorway does not make this entirely clear.

But the main point is that Highways England needed third parties to inform it of the incident and close the lane.

Its guidance page states: ‘Our regional control centres use CCTV cameras to monitor and manage our motorways. Once they’re aware of your situation (via CCTV or the police), they can set overhead signs and close the lane to help keep traffic away from you.’

This is where the AA comes in. It pointed out, as Highways has pointed out, that only a fraction of the all lane running schemes have a radar system that can detect stationary vehicles and that in their absence it can take an average of 17 minutes for Highways England to detect a stopped vehicle in a live lane.

It doesn’t help, the AA said, that CCTV cameras might be pointed in the wrong direction at the time of an incident.

In my Highways article, I noted that two fatalities had occurred on all lane running stretches of the M1 in the last year where vehicles have driven into stationary vehicles in live lanes. It is unclear whether red Xs (which have a relatively low compliance rate) had been used to close those lanes.

This last weekend, it was revealed that the widow of a driver, Jason Mercer, who was killed in a crash on a smart motorway is to sue Highways England for corporate manslaughter.

The incident, which was also on the M1, also cost the life of another driver, Alexandru Murgeanu. The men had stopped to exchange insurance details after a minor collision. The paper quotes Clare Mercer as saying that the police told her the lane was not closed.

The 17 minutes statistic cited by the AA actually comes from a Highways Englang report on the benefits of using stationary (or stopped) vehicle detection (SVD). That report concludes that ‘the positive benefits exceed the costs of the implementation when the overall duration of each stopped vehicle incident is reduced because the incident is detected more quickly’, which is what SVD does, all other things being equal.

In cash terms, the benefit cost ratio (BCR) ‘improves with size of scheme’, with a BCR of 1.42 for a 20 km scheme versus 1.72 for 100km. These are of course human lives and serious injuries we are talking about.

Highways England said last week that it agrees that SVD works and is ‘being designed into all the smart motorway projects that we start constructing from next year’, ie the second Road Investment Strategy.

As far as existing schemes are concerned, although work is underway on installing SVD on the M3 in Surrey and Hampshire, Highways England said it is only ‘looking how we could provide the same benefits on all our other recently opened smart motorway upgrades’.

This lack of a commitment suggests that Highways England is not going to be installing SVD on the M1 anytime soon and there also appears to be no commitment at all to install SVD on schemes currently under construction - including a £373m scheme covering a further 37.9km  of the M1 involving ‘low light/infrared CCTV cameras to provide 100% coverage’.

In its answer to the AA’s Freedom of Information request, Highways England said its ‘commitment is that all ALR schemes will have SVD capability’. It also said: ‘For the remaining ALR schemes which are in design or construction, or are now in operation we are looking at alternative solutions as technology capability continues to advance.’

The apparent contradiction may be resolved by the possibility that ‘alternative solutions’ may still detect stationary vehicles without being strictly labelled ‘SVD’, but again the impression is that we should not hold our breath waiting for this truly smart capability to be used across what Highways England calls ‘smart motorways’, irrespective of whether it is in place.

Register now for full access

Register just once to get unrestricted, real-time coverage of the issues and challenges facing UK transport and highways engineers.

Full website content includes the latest news, exclusive commentary from leading industry figures and detailed topical analysis of the highways, transportation, environment and place-shaping sectors. Use the link below to register your details for full, free access.

Already a registered? Login

comments powered by Disqus
highways jobs

Green Space Partnership Officer

Camden London Borough Council
£30,066 - £34,538
You will have excellent written and presentation skills including experience of preparation of reports, briefings, minutes of meetings and... Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Sustainability Officer

Camden London Borough Council
£33,122 - £38,423
Looking for two Sustainability Officers to work across the Sustainability, Air Quality and Energy team to create, manage and... Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Parking Projects Manager

Brent Council
£45,585 - £48,482 p.a. inc.
As Parking Projects Manager, you will be responsible for leading the delivery, to time and budget, of key parking projects... Wembley, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Brent Council

Parking Operations Officer

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£19,554 - £21,166
Are you a hard-working individual, who enjoys working outdoors in all weather conditions? Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Team Leader (Local Plan)

City of Bradford MDC
£40,760 - £43,662 pa
The post requires a degree and eligible to be a corporate member of Royal Town Planning Institute and NVQ Level 5 in Management or... Bradford, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: City of Bradford MDC

Team Leader (Infrastructure & Local Plan Implementation)

City of Bradford MDC
£42,683 pa - £45,591 pa
The Post provides an exciting opportunity to manage a multidisciplinary team of professionals leading on Transport planning and Local Plan Bradford, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: City of Bradford MDC

Environmental Health Officer

Camden London Borough Council
£32,473 - £42,490
Seeking Environmental Health Officers to contribute towards delivering the project objectives of addressing rogue landlords and... Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Neighbourhood Highway Engineer

Devon County Council
£36,876 to £40,760 per annum
Seeking an experienced highway engineer with extensive knowledge of highway maintenance and traffic management to... Devon
Recuriter: Devon County Council

Road Safety and Sustainable Transport Assistant

Telford & Wrekin Council
SCP 13-17 - £11.41 - £12.35
Exciting opportunity to join Telford & Wrekin Council’s Highways, Transport & Engineering, Road Safety & Sustainable Transport Team. Telford, Shropshire
Recuriter: Telford & Wrekin Council

Project Assistant

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£26,999 - £29,636
Looking for an additional team member to support the Senior Environmental Health Officers in undertaking complex Air Quality Improvement Projects... Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Principal Road Safety Officer

Royal Borough of Greenwich
£42684 - £45585 per annum
We are looking a fantastic new road safety expert to lead our high performing and innovative Road Safety Team.The Royal Borough of Greenwich is commit England, London, Woolwich
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Principal Development Co-ordinator

Gloucestershire County Council
£33,799.00 - £38,813.00 plus 12% supplement*
Looking for those who will quickly understand the Gloucestershire context and can display their expertise and... Gloucestershire
Recuriter: Gloucestershire County Council

Team Leaders

Gloucestershire County Council
£43,662.00 - £45,591.00 plus 12% supplement*
Looking for those who will quickly understand the Gloucestershire context and can display their expertise and solid professional experience in... Gloucestershire
Recuriter: Gloucestershire County Council

Highways Project Manager  

Gloucestershire County Council
£43,662.00 - £45,591.00 plus 12% supplement*
Looking for those who will quickly understand the Gloucestershire context and can display their expertise and... Gloucestershire
Recuriter: Gloucestershire County Council

HDM - Team Manager

Gloucestershire County Council
£49,472.00 - £52,327.00 plus 12% supplement*
Looking for those who will quickly understand the Gloucestershire context and can display their expertise and... Gloucestershire
Recuriter: Gloucestershire County Council

Ugobus Driver (multiple positions)

Essex County Council
Up to £18938 per annum
Please note that we have permanent, fixed term and relief contract opportunities on a part time, job share and flexible working basis. The salary is u England, Essex, Chelmsford
Recuriter: Essex County Council

Inspector (Street Works)

Bedford Borough Council
£27,905 - £30,507 per annum
You will inspect the highways at agreed frequencies in order to maintain the highway in a safe and usable condition. Bedford, Bedfordshire
Recuriter: Bedford Borough Council

Commercial Projects Manager

Wirral Borough Council
£38,813 - £41,675)
In this role, you’ll help to develop the Council’s internal highway design traded service Wirral, Merseyside
Recuriter: Wirral Borough Council

Service Director, Street Services

Plymouth City Council
£75-105k per annum
A city to be proud of Plymouth, Devon
Recuriter: Plymouth City Council

Primary Authority Officer / Environmental Health Officer

North West Leicestershire District Council
Band F, £29,636 - £32,878 per annum
Your time will be evenly split between the Primary Authority role with HMS Host and delivering food safety and health and safety interventions. Coalville, Leicestershire
Recuriter: North West Leicestershire District Council