UK infrastructure plagued by 'poor decisions and short-termism'

 

A leading think tank has criticised the UK's approach to infrastructure investment and delivery, stating it 'consistently makes poor decisions' and is short sighted.

”Local

Developed over a year, the latest infrastructure report from the Institute for Government explores how the UK can improve infrastructure policymaking in areas including transport, energy, flood defences, digital communication, waste and water.

It slams the Government for not having a long-term approach to infrastructure and for failing to make timely decisions or engage effectively with the public to address concerns, as well having a poor approach to capital investment.

It provides a list of recommendations covering key areas such as time, quality and cost.

Recommendations:

Time

1) The Government must strengthen the National Infrastructure Commission (NIC).

The report calls for the NIC to be given greater independence as an executive non-departmental public body, have a more diverse array of professions and backgrounds in its commissioners, engage the public more widely and have its remit extended to housing.

The Government had initially pledged to make the NIC a statutory body but has since rowed back on giving it statutory status.

2) The Government must create a Commission for Public Engagement.

The report states that the UK should learn Learning from France’s Commission Nationale du Débat Public (CNDP) and create a Commission for Public Engagement as a cost-effective way of giving 'local communities a genuine opportunity to shape infrastructure decisions, helping to deliver major projects faster and more efficiently'.

Quality

3) The Government needs a cross-government infrastructure strategy.

This would articulate a vision for how the policies and projects of individual departments interact to achieve infrastructure objectives and explain how the capacity of sub-national authorities will be built.

'To help develop the strategy and monitor its implementation, the Government should reinstate the position of Commercial Secretary to the Treasury,' the report states.

4) The Government must improve cost benefit analysis.

  • update cost benefit analysis so that it can better capture the ‘dynamic effects’ of projects
  • improve the accuracy of project cost and time estimates
  • take a more consistent approach to assessing projects
  • communicate cost benefit analysis results within Whitehall and to the public better.

5) Parliament must scrutinise infrastructure decisions made by the Government better.

In the House of Commons, the Treasury Committee should lead this, working closely with other relevant committees. In the House of Lords, a new infrastructure committee should be established, initially for a year.

6) Individual departments must learn from past projects

Departments must consistently evaluate infrastructure projects, systematically collecting data on:

  • cost outturns against estimates
  • delivery times against estimates
  • the size of project teams
  • project length.

7) The Government must improve its approach to accounting, appraisal and budgeting

'Government must not let arbitrary accounting rules and narrow fiscal targets drive financing decisions, it must implement a more robust appraisal process and it must change the way that the Treasury handles capital investment.'

8) The Government needs to up its game in terms of private finance

  • The Government must ensure that civil servants have access to sufficient in-house commercial skills.
  • Ministers need to understand investor perspectives better before making policy.
  • And the Infrastructure and Projects Authority must outline a clear infrastructure project pipeline that provides investors with clarity on which projects will require private finance, how much investment is needed, and how the deals will be structured.
 

Also see

Register now for full access


Register just once to get unrestricted, real-time coverage of the issues and challenges facing UK transport and highways engineers.

Full website content includes the latest news, exclusive commentary from leading industry figures and detailed topical analysis of the highways, transportation, environment and place-shaping sectors. Use the link below to register your details for full, free access.

Already a registered? Login

 
comments powered by Disqus
 
 
highways jobs

Transport Development Control Team Leader

Oxfordshire County Council
£48,551 - £55,374
We need visionary Team Leaders to help our people meet their targets. Oxford, Oxfordshire
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

Programme Manager Central

Oxfordshire County Council
£37,107 - £43,757
We’re on a mission to enhance Oxfordshire – and with you by our side, that vision just became a reality. Oxford, Oxfordshire
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

Infrastructure Locality Lead

Oxfordshire County Council
£48,551 - £55,374
We need visionary Team Leaders to help our people meet their targets. Oxford, Oxfordshire
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

Growth & Place Special Projects Officers

Oxfordshire County Council
£48,551 - £55,374
Join us in a large-scale role that will span several years, and play a vital part in supporting major infrastructure schemes. Oxford, Oxfordshire
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

Site Inspectors

Oxfordshire County Council
£29,909- £36,153
You will provide specialist technical support to some of the most imaginative transport and town planning challenges imaginable. Oxford, Oxfordshire
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

Planning Obligations Team Member

Oxfordshire County Council
£21,074 - £29,055
You will witness first-hand the exciting developments currently taking place in Oxfordshire Oxford, Oxfordshire
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

Planning Obligations Manager

Oxfordshire County Council
£37,107 - £47,575
Committed to supporting growth across the county, you will ensure financial contributions are being actively and efficiently managed. Oxford, Oxfordshire
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

Assistant Planners (Transport & General)

Oxfordshire County Council
£21,074 - £29,055
You will witness first-hand the exciting developments currently taking place in Oxfordshire. Oxford, Oxfordshire
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

Planners (Transport & General)

Oxfordshire County Council
£29,909 - £36,153
You will provide specialist technical support to some of the most imaginative transport and town planning challenges imaginable. Oxford
Recuriter: Oxfordshire County Council

High Speed 2 (HS2) Community Liaison Advisor

East Midlands Shared Services
£31,464
Leicestershire County Council is looking for someone to support our proactive approach to HS2 Phase 2b for Leicestershire Leicestershire
Recuriter: East Midlands Shared Services

High Speed 2 (HS2) Project Manager

East Midlands Shared Services
£39,903
Leicestershire County Council is looking for someone to manage a proactive approach to HS2 Phase 2b for Leicestershire. Leicestershire
Recuriter: East Midlands Shared Services

High Speed 2 (HS2) Programme Lead

East Midlands Shared Services
£59,652
Leicestershire County Council is looking for someone to lead a proactive approach to HS2 Phase 2b for Leicestershire. Leicestershire
Recuriter: East Midlands Shared Services

Lincolnshire Waste Partnership Programme Delivery Manager

Lincolnshire County Council
£38,052 - £42,806
The Lincolnshire Waste Partnership (LWP) is seeking a committed and enthusiastic Programme Delivery Manager Lincolnshire
Recuriter: Lincolnshire County Council

Head of Customs

St Helena
£55k pa, taxable in St Helena; a tax free International Supplement will also apply
Could you lead the HMCE team to efficiently implement the Customs & Excise Ordinance in border protection Saint Helena (SH)
Recuriter: St Helena

Highways Maintenance Manager

Plymouth City Council
£37,107 to £41,846
We are looking for a dynamic Highways Manager to lead and co-ordinate all our maintenance activities Plymouth, Devon
Recuriter: Plymouth City Council

Neighbourhood Services Operations Manager

East Lindsey District Council
£30,756 - £35,229 per annum (Grade 7)
This is an exciting opportunity to oversee the delivery of the cleansing and grounds maintenance function in one of the largest Districts of the UK Manby, Louth
Recuriter: East Lindsey District Council

Assistant Highways Officer (North & South Kesteven)

Lincolnshire County Council
£19,819 - £22,401
Lincolnshire County Council is looking to recruit an Assistant Highways Officer to support the Local Highways Management Team Lincolnshire
Recuriter: Lincolnshire County Council

Chief Executive

Sutton London Borough Council
Competitive Salary
We believe that such important agendas require exemplary leadership. Sutton, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Sutton London Borough Council

Project Engineers

North Yorkshire County Council
£24,313 to £34,788, dependent upon experience.
We are looking for Project Engineers to join our Highways and Transportation service based across North Yorkshire. North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire County Council

Improvement/Maintenance Managers

North Yorkshire County Council
Up to £49,003, including winter working allowances
Are you an experienced professional looking for a management opportunity? North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire County Council