Sexed-up? HS2 report being rewritten


The Department for Transport (DfT) has denied that it has the final report of the 'independent' HS2 review but has refused to clarify its own role in the rewriting of the 'draft' document.

Although the BBC claimed last week that it has seen the 'full and final' report, DfT press officers have continued to maintain that the department has only received a 'draft report' and that review chair Doug Oakervee is still working on the final document.

The BBC's account of the report is markedly different to an earlier version seen by Lord Berkeley who was deputy chair of the review but quit, refusing to put his name to what he saw as a whitewash in favour of the scheme.   

Whose draft is it anyway?

So why the difference between the early draft report, the DfT's 'draft' report and the BBC's 'final' report?

Lord Berkeley has alleged a programme of 'continuous improvement' is taking place i.e. sexing up the document to ensure that HS2 is approved.

The DfT has repeatedly stated that ‘a draft of the Oakervee Report was delivered shortly before Christmas’, adding that the transport secretary, chancellor and prime minister would take a final decision on the project ‘shortly’.

It has now admitted that after receiving the 'draft report' from Mr Oakervee it tasked a group of officials to carry our further research but denied this would see them work on the report itself.

When asked whether the work of these officials would influence the final report, a press officer stated that 'Oakervee is writing the report' but refused to say whether the DfT would edit the report or ask Mr Oakervee to do so on the basis of this further work.

When asked to confirm or deny whether the department would make an changes to the draft or final report, the spokesman repeated the phrase 'Oakervee is writing the report' and once again refused to engage with the question of influence or editing. 

The spokesman also claimed that the report was still in draft reform - and so running months late - because of the general election, depite the fact the final report was due to be handed in before the election in the autumn, that the case for HS2 predates the general election anouncement by some years and the fact that the review was supposed to be 'independent' of politics.

Andy McDonald, Labour's shadow transport sectretary, told Transport Network: ‘Ministers have had Doug Oakervee’s HS2 review for months. They should publish the report, make the necessary revisions to the project and get on with HS2.’

The BBC and a 'sexed-up' document

The BBC correspondent who reported the most recent leak described the report as ‘supportive’, despite the report apparently acknowledging that ‘the latest results indicate that the full y-shaped network represents “low-medium” value for money’.

Last week, former deputy chair Lord Berkeley told Transport Network that leaks of what the BBC described as the ‘full and final’ report were very different from a draft that he saw in October.

He said: ‘'I suspect there has been continuous improvement [of the case for HS2] without anyone knowing.’

Significantly, according to the BBC journalist who has seen the ‘full and final’ report, it recommends that the DfT should produce a revised business case for the project.

This would reportedly include ‘reducing the central planning assumption for HS2 to a more realistic 14 trains per hour (current plan is for 18 trains per hour, which has never been achieved anywhere in the world), while future-proofing the scheme for 16tph and noting a loss of assumed benefits.

This appears to confirm a key point made by Lord Berkeley, a longstanding critic of HS2, that a business case based on 18 trains per hour is unrealistic.

According to leaks from the report, it argues that ‘Initial analysis suggests that a move below 16 tph would likely have a marginal negative impact on the Benefit Cost Ratio’.

Register now for full access

Register just once to get unrestricted, real-time coverage of the issues and challenges facing UK transport and highways engineers.

Full website content includes the latest news, exclusive commentary from leading industry figures and detailed topical analysis of the highways, transportation, environment and place-shaping sectors. Use the link below to register your details for full, free access.

Already a registered? Login

comments powered by Disqus
highways jobs

Community Services Manager

Copeland Borough Council
Competitive Salary
Looking for an energised and enthusiastic candidate to lead and focus the service through the challenges set by the Resources and Waste Strategy. Moresby, Whitehaven
Recuriter: Copeland Borough Council

Highways Infrastructure and Maintenance Manager - Highways Network

Bridgend County Borough Council
£37,813 - £40,760 per annum
An exciting opportunity has arrived inside the Highway Asset Maintenance Team within the Communities Directorate. Bridgend (Pen-y-bont ar Ogwr)
Recuriter: Bridgend County Borough Council

Business Support Officers - Transport Team (2 Jobs)

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£19,554 - £21,166
Within the Transport Team you will be required to work flexibly in accordance with the needs of the service, which can men... Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Transportation Planning Manager

Brent Council
£55,638 - £58,779 p.a. inc.
ou will have an excellent knowledge and understanding of transport policy at both local and national level. Expertise of both people and... Wembley, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Brent Council

Commercial Contract Supervisor

Wirral Borough Council
£30,507 to £32,878
No holding back. No excuses. Just change Wirral. Wirral, Merseyside
Recuriter: Wirral Borough Council

Technical Officer – Pest Control

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£19,554 - £23,836
This job is temporary for up to 11 months from the date of appointment to cover the absence of the current post holder. Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Divisional Director Neighbourhoods & Sustainability

Glasgow City Council
£83,708 - £95,232 (LDR3a, Grade 11)
This innovative role will contribute to the Council Strategic Plan Theme of A Sustainable Low Carbon City Glasgow, Glasgow City
Recuriter: Glasgow City Council

Business Support Officer - Bereavement Services

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£18,795 - £19,171
You will be required to work front line with customers who are ordering memorials, our customers may be... Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Senior Traffic Engineer

East Riding of Yorkshire Council
£32.029 - £34.788
We seek an enthusiastic and experienced traffic engineer to manage our Traffic Team. East Riding of Yorkshire
Recuriter: East Riding of Yorkshire Council

Principal Transport Manager

Be First
Competitive Salary
As our Principal Transport Manager, you will deliver the Local Implementation Plan, ensuring the £2.4million TFL budget is used effectively London (Central), London (Greater)
Recuriter: Be First

Highway Operations Manager

Croydon London Borough Council
£43,590 - £45,585
We are seeking an enthusiastic, motivated and well organised highway operations manager Croydon (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recuriter: Croydon London Borough Council

Structures and Watercourse Manager

Croydon London Borough Council
We are seeking an enthusiastic, motivated and well organised manager to look over the structures team and wider Highway section. Croydon (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recuriter: Croydon London Borough Council

Chartered Environmental Health Traineeship

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
National Minimum Wage (Age appropriate) plus enhancements for night time working
During your two years with us you will... Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Project Managers & Engineers (Highways/Transport Team)

Southwark London Borough Council
£36,486 - £43,404
If you have the relevant experience and you think you could contribute to our enthusiastic team environment, then we’d be delighted to hear from you. Southwark, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Southwark London Borough Council

Environmental Health Technician

North West Leicestershire District Council
Band E, £25,295 - £28,785 per annum
The successful candidate will get the opportunity to undertake a rich variety of food safety, workplace health and safety and public health duties. Coalville, Leicestershire
Recuriter: North West Leicestershire District Council

EHO/Surveyor Private Sector Housing

Brent Council
35,724 - £41,706 p.a. inc.
The council is pursuing a far-reaching transformation agenda that better meets the needs of our community so it is an exciting time to join us. Wembley, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Brent Council

(Senior) Environmental Health Officer/Enforcement Officer

Brent Council
£35,724 - £41,706 p.a. inc.
Looking to appoint Environmental Health Officers to join our Food and Health & Safety Team, covering the... Wembley, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Brent Council

Strategic Manager Highways and Transport

Isle of Wight Council
£65,620.00 to £70,915.00
Are you are looking for an ambitious and rewarding career move to one of the best places to live and work in the country? Isle of Wight
Recuriter: Isle of Wight Council

Senior Technician - Network Management

West Berkshire Council
£22.911 to £28.785 per annum (Grade G)
Looking for a Senior Technician who will have the opportunity to help in the design and construction of a variety of highway improvement projects. Newbury, Berkshire
Recuriter: West Berkshire Council

Senior Technician - Asset Management

West Berkshire Council
£22.911 to £28.785 per annum (Grade G)
You should be educated to HNC level (or equivalent) with at least 3 years post qualification experience relevant to the provision of this service. Newbury, Berkshire
Recuriter: West Berkshire Council