Over-optimistic TfL in 'a perilous financial situation', committee says


London Assembly members have warned mayor Sadiq Khan that he should publish the cost of a new fare freeze as Transport for London (TfL) faces ‘unprecedented’ financial pressure.

With TfL running a deficit of £1bn for 2018/19, and delays to the Elizabeth line (Crossrail) adding to its problems, the London Assembly’s Budget and Performance Committee has released a report into TfL’s finances and how they can be turned around.

The report comes shortly after the transport secretary himself said TfL was in 'deep financial difficulties'.


Committee chairman Gareth Bacon said: ‘The first-term partial fares freeze will end up costing TfL at least £640m; a second-term freeze could be substantially more, and it is simply not sustainable if TfL is to claw its way out of a perilous financial situation.

‘Freezing fares is a political decision that the Mayor can take but Londoners deserves to know exactly how much it will cost.’

He added: ‘TfL needs to have a period of calm in which they make sensible, sure-footed and long sighted financial decisions as part of a concrete plan to get out of the financial doldrums it has found itself in.’

The committee also said the Government should draw up plans to devolve Vehicle Excise Duty revenue to London – a key ask of the mayor and London’s boroughs – and that TfL should commission and publish market research into new forms of advertising on its network, with proposals put out for public consultation.

The report states: ‘Overall, we have concerns about TfL’s optimism. TfL still says it will break even by 2021-22, even with the delay to Crossrail. This would be a huge achievement.’

A TfL spokesperson said the organisation would publish a five-year Business Plan by the end of the year that will describe how it will manage the impact of the delay to the Elizabeth line and welcomed the committee’s call to Government ‘for a sustainable way in which to fund the maintenance of London’s road network’.

The spokesperson said: ‘As the Committee notes, we continue to grip operating costs with more than £500m per annum in savings so far and raising more revenue through our property, advertising and other commercial assets.

‘This strong track record of cost reduction and broadening revenue streams is enabling us to work towards an operating surplus while dealing with the difficult challenges of the withdrawal of £700m per annum in Government operating grant and a subdued economy that has resulted in lower revenues.’


Also see

Register now for full access

Register just once to get unrestricted, real-time coverage of the issues and challenges facing UK transport and highways engineers.

Full website content includes the latest news, exclusive commentary from leading industry figures and detailed topical analysis of the highways, transportation, environment and place-shaping sectors. Use the link below to register your details for full, free access.

Already a registered? Login

comments powered by Disqus