DfT pulls off ‘risky’ U-turn on Severn bridges

 

On Transport Network’s sister website, Highways, we reveal that Highways England has suffered a hit to its finances of around £45m after responsibility for the Severn Crossings was transferred to it without additional funding.

The issue seems to stem from a change of heart during the 2017 General Election campaign when a Government proposal to cut tolls on the two bridges and definitely not abolish them became a Conservative pledge to...well, abolish them.

As we have reported, tolls to use the original (M48) Severn Bridge and what is now the M4 Prince of Wales Bridge westbound, otherwise known as a ‘tax on entering Wales’, were abolished last month.

This became possible when the crossings came back under public control in January 2018 after toll income hit a financial target, allowing the Department for Transport (DfT) to forego the roughly £100m a year in revenue the tolls brought in.

However it gave Highways England no additional funding to maintain them until the end of Roads Period 1 in 2020.

While the abolition of tolls might at first seem to be not so much as a U-turn as a continuation of the same direction of travel, it’s worth looking back at the DfT’s January 2017 consultation on the proposed reduction of charges, which gave a number of reasons why abolition was not merely ‘not proposed’ but seemingly out of the question.

”Local

These included the stark statement that ‘this would put at risk the future of the Crossings’, not least because: ‘The reality is that given the size and complexity of these structures there will always be a cost to ensuring their safe operation.’

The document pointed out that ‘the Crossings cost approximately £15m each year to operate and maintain’ and that ‘Highways England estimate that likely resurfacing of the Severn Bridge after the end of the concession period will cost in the region of £12m’.

In addition: ‘The Government is also concerned that reduced tolls could result in increased traffic and congestion in areas surrounding the Crossings, both in Bristol and along the M4 in Wales, where there are already concerns about congestion levels. Reducing the tolls by 50% would allow us to assess the impact, on the Crossing and more generally, of increased traffic flows.’

Highways has calculated that the costs of maintaining and operating the bridges between January 2018 and March 2020 will be approximately £33m, plus at least £12m resurfacing costs, which could increase.

The DfT consultation document described the idea that the additional traffic caused but abolishing tolls could lead to increased economic growth and therefore higher tax revenues that could pay ongoing costs as an ‘an attractive theory’ but an uncertain one, warning that ‘the taxpayer could end up out of pocket, or the future of the Crossings could be put at risk’.

It continued: ‘For this reason, and in line with the Government’s longstanding policy that users of estuarial crossings should pay for their upkeep, the Government is not consulting on the complete removal of the tolls. Instead the Government believes it is better to put in place a more sure and sustainable plan that balances the needs of users and taxpayers and guarantees the continued running and upkeep of the Crossings.’

Users of estuarial crossings elsewhere, such as at Dartford or the Humber, who continue to pay for their upkeep have of course noticed. Last September, the Liverpool Echo observed: ‘With a date soon to be released for when South Wales' Severn Bridges tolls will be scrapped, many in the North West may wonder when their own infrastructure to cross the River Mersey will also be free of charge.’

On the other hand, users of the new Queensferry Crossing across the Forth get off Scot-free.

In addition, the DfT consultation stated: ‘During the course of the concession the Government incurred approximately £63m to cover the costs of fixing latent defects on the Severn Bridge and this money still needs to be recovered.’

While the DfT told Highways that the £63m was recovered, presumably from the near £100m income it received before tolls were abolished in December, Highways England has said that it remains committed to resurfacing the original bridge from its own pocket.

It will also have to fund ongoing maintenance from its 2015-2020 budget until it feels the benefit of an increased allocation for 2020-25 under the National Roads Fund.

Who would have thought such a thing possible? Not someone who read the DfT’s 2017 consultation.

Register now for full access


Register just once to get unrestricted, real-time coverage of the issues and challenges facing UK transport and highways engineers.

Full website content includes the latest news, exclusive commentary from leading industry figures and detailed topical analysis of the highways, transportation, environment and place-shaping sectors. Use the link below to register your details for full, free access.

Already a registered? Login

 
comments powered by Disqus
 
 
highways jobs

Highways Asset & Maintenance Manager

Brighton & Hove City Council
£42,806 - £46,326
Looking to recruit a new Highways Asset and Maintenance Manager Brighton, East Sussex
Recuriter: Brighton & Hove City Council

Senior Development Engineer

Bristol City Council
£27,358 - £33,136
Bristol is an exciting, and culturally thriving Regional Capital City of Bristol
Recuriter: Bristol City Council

Executive Director Place & Economy

Peterborough City & Cambridgeshire County Councils
Competitive salary
The opportunity to combine major services across a city and a county to contribute to the delivery of future growth and Infrastructure Cambridgeshire
Recuriter: Peterborough City & Cambridgeshire County Councils

Head of Culture & Place

The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council
up to £78,800 plus PRP
This could not be a more important time to join Kensington and Chelsea Kensington and Chelsea, London (Greater)
Recuriter: The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council

Director for Cleaner, Greener & Cultural Services

The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council
up to £103,500 plus PRP
This could not be a more important time to join Kensington and Chelsea Kensington and Chelsea, London (Greater)
Recuriter: The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council

Director for Public Protection

The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council
up to £103,500 plus PRP
This could not be a more important time to join Kensington and Chelsea Kensington and Chelsea, London (Greater)
Recuriter: The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea Council

Chief Executive

Luton Borough Council
Luton Borough Council
Recuriter: Luton Borough Council

Head of Democratic Services

Ealing London Borough Council
£58,650.00 - £61,737.00
Ealing is an exciting place to live and work, and local democracy is at the heart of its success. Ealing, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Ealing London Borough Council

Director of Development and Environment

North Somerset Council
circa £125,000 p.a.
We are looking for an experienced and enthusiastic individual to maintain momentum on delivery of our regeneration and placemaking aspirations Somerset
Recuriter: North Somerset Council

Development Officer/Senior Development Officer

Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council
£28,221 - £35,229 / £33,136 - £41,846
Seeking an individual to lead on all aspects of Highways advice to a busy Development Management team Solihull, West Midlands
Recuriter: Solihull Metropolitan Borough Council

Highways Asset & Maintenance Manager

Brighton & Hove City Council
£42,806 - £46,326
Looking to recruit a new Highways Asset and Maintenance Manager Brighton, East Sussex
Recuriter: Brighton & Hove City Council

Commercial Manager

Leicester City Council
£41,846 - £44,697
Seeking for a Comercial Manager to work for the Leicester City Council. Leicester, Leicestershire
Recuriter: Leicester City Council

Senior Highways Development Engineer

Leeds City Council
£37,107 - £39,961
Seeking to appoint an experienced highways engineer or transport planner. Leeds, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Leeds City Council

Trainee Deputy Editor of Bridge Design & Engineering

Bridge Design & Engineering
£24,000-26,000
Bd&e is looking for a structural or civil engineering graduate with a passion for bridges. Dorset
Recuriter: Bridge Design & Engineering

Strategic Transport Project Development Officer

Hull City Council
£36.153 - £39.002
Would you like to work in the successful UK City of Culture? Kingston upon Hull, East Riding of Yorkshire
Recuriter: Hull City Council

Project Lead

Hull City Council
£45.181 - £48.563
Would you like to work in the successful UK City of Culture? Kingston upon Hull, East Riding of Yorkshire
Recuriter: Hull City Council

Highway Development Control Officer

Hull City Council
£31.401 - £34.106
Would you like to work in the successful UK City of Culture? Kingston upon Hull, East Riding of Yorkshire
Recuriter: Hull City Council

Highway / Traffic Development / Design Technician - Three posts

Hull City Council
£28221 - £30756
Would you like to work in the successful UK City of Culture? Kingston upon Hull, East Riding of Yorkshire
Recuriter: Hull City Council

Assistant Director - Economy & Regeneration

Babergh & Mid Suffolk
Up to £72k
Quality of work, quality of life, along with a generous relocation package and flexible working patterns. Ipswich, Suffolk
Recuriter: Babergh & Mid Suffolk

Assistant Director - Environment & Commercial Services

Babergh & Mid Suffolk
Up to £72k
Quality of work, quality of life, along with a generous relocation package and flexible working patterns Ipswich, Suffolk
Recuriter: Babergh & Mid Suffolk

Chief Executive

Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council
c£160,000
Barnsley is a Council with ambition, flair and imagination Barnsley, South Yorkshire
Recuriter: Barnsley Metropolitan Borough Council