Controversy mounts over Silvertown tunnel


A local campaign group fighting the Silvertown Tunnel has raised concerns over due diligence and the background business case.

The Stop Silvertown campaign, which has garnered support from the Green Party and London councillors, has been steadily building its profile after Transport for London (TfL) awarded the contract for the £1bn project recently.

An FOI request sent by the campaigners revealed that despite assurances from the mayor's team that all alternative options to the tunnel were considered there seems to have been a lack of in-depth analysis of the single bore option.

TfL has sought to shrug off the accusations of misleading the public after deputy mayor Heidi Alexander wrote to campaigners stating: 'The case for the scheme also includes consideration of a single bore option with tidal flow.

'This option was ruled out due to substantial safety, operational and engineering challenges. While it is not explicitly referenced in the case for the scheme, a key reason for ruling out this option was that a single bore would need to be large enough to accomodate an emergency services access route and this is not feasible due to restrictied land availablity on both sides of the river.'

Ms Alexander also highlighted that TfL's conclusions were endorsed by the Development Consent Order Panel and the secretary of state, who in granting consent agreed with the panel that 'there has been sufficient assessment of alternatives'.

However, TfLs internal emails obtained by FOI suggest a discrepancy. 

Emails sent to David Rowe, head of Silvertown Tunnel Sponsorship at TfL, noted: 'Single bore bidirectional can be very robustly rejected on safety grounds ie not feasible.

  • 'Single bore one direction was considered for Blackwall and not considered feasible or operatioanlly desirable.
  • 'But single bore silvertown operated tidally we haven't covered in depth in the exam.'
  • A follow up email said: 'I hope the rather brief response doesn't turn out to trip us up - to be quite honest I'm slightly regretting the 'all feasible options' line...'

A TfL spokesperson said: 'A single bore option was actively considered in the design process early on. It is important to recognise that tunnels are safety critical environments where the impact of collisions and fires pose even greater risk to road users. The confined space within tunnels can make evacuation and emergency services access much more difficult.

'Consequently, a significantly larger single bore tunnel would be required to enable the emergency services to access it and safely evacuate. However, due to the limited land and physical constraints on either side of the river, there is insufficient space for a such a design. Due to these reasons and wider operational and safety concerns associated with tidal operation, a single bore tunnel was ruled out.

'Our conclusion was endorsed by the DCO Panel and by the secretary of state, who in granting consent confirmed: ‘The Secretary of State notes the options appraised and alternatives canvassed… and he agrees with the Panel that there has been sufficient assessment of alternatives’.'

Business case

The Stop Silvertown campaign also noted that the business case rests on a charge for the tunnel, which could be reduced at any future mayor's discretion after consultation with organisations representative of regular tunnel users - who might well be supportive of lowerng the charge.

If future tunnel charges were lowered this could also result in induced traffic demand in the area, creating more congestion. 

The Stop Silvertown campaign said: 'All the congestion and air quality forecasts for the Silvertown Tunnel project are an elaborate fiction - because they're all based on the pretence that future Mayors will set exactly the level of toll that this mayor wants them to set.'

A TfL spokesman highlighted that the DCO states clearly that the tunnel has to be subject to a user charge – so there is no option to not to have a user charge.

London mayor's are often tempted to promise fare and toll reductions and freezes, however they often do not live up to these promises such is the pressure on TfL's budget. Mayor Khan is a noticeable exception to this and has run into funding issues as a result.

Register now for full access

Register just once to get unrestricted, real-time coverage of the issues and challenges facing UK transport and highways engineers.

Full website content includes the latest news, exclusive commentary from leading industry figures and detailed topical analysis of the highways, transportation, environment and place-shaping sectors. Use the link below to register your details for full, free access.

Already a registered? Login

comments powered by Disqus
highways jobs

Chair of the Board of Directors - Norwich City Services

Norwich City Council
£10,000 per annum
Join Norwich City Services Ltd and transform the way we look after our city and our people. Norwich, Norfolk
Recuriter: Norwich City Council

Team Leader

Buckinghamshire Council
OverviewThis is your chance to make a lasting impact on our county. From developing the connected transport networks of the future and driving sustain England, Buckinghamshire, Aylesbury
Recuriter: Buckinghamshire Council

Commercial Vehicle Technician

Chelmsford City Council
£30,000 per annum
We are seeking a fully trained HGV technician to work as part of the team who maintain the Council's fleet to the highest standards.  Chelmsford, Essex
Recuriter: Chelmsford City Council

Environmental Protection Officer x2

Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council
£24,313 - £28,785 per annum
You will also be required to undertake a basic DBS check if successful. Sandwell, West Midlands
Recuriter: Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council

Head of Operations

Rossendale Borough Council
£49,408 - £52,899
Our Operations Service is the largest single service at Rossendale Council and one of the most important. Rossendale, Lancashire
Recuriter: Rossendale Borough Council

Business Support Officer - Environmental Health - up to 2 jobs

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£18,795 - £19,171
You will be part of a small team providing business and administrative support in the Environmental Service which is made up of... Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Civil Enforcement Officer

Northumberland County Council
£21,589 - £23,836
Civil Enforcement Officers required for Berwick, Morpeth, Blyth and Hexham areas. Berwick, Morpeth, Blyth and Hexham areas
Recuriter: Northumberland County Council

Chief Executive

Basingstoke & Deane Borough Council
Package to £149k
Seeking applications from impressive, broadspectrum leaders, with a close and agile understanding of the opportunities and challenges that lie ahead. Basingstoke, Hampshire
Recuriter: Basingstoke & Deane Borough Council

Director, Place & Environment

Walsall Council
Up to £81,647 - £94,208 + benefits
Put your all into Walsall Walsall, West Midlands
Recuriter: Walsall Council

Development Management Engineer

Warwickshire County Council
£37,849 - £39,782 per annum
The successful applicant for this post will be capable of taking the lead on work within... Warwick, Warwickshire
Recuriter: Warwickshire County Council

Apprentice Gas Heating Engineer

City of York Council
£12,443.89 per annum
You will work within the Heating Team (Building Services) and with other teams to deliver a Heating Repairs Service to the residents of York. York, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: City of York Council

2x Environmental Health Officer

Dacorum Borough Council
Up to £42,336
We are seeking to appoint two qualified Environmental Health Officers to work within our Environmental Health Team Dacorum, Hertfordshire
Recuriter: Dacorum Borough Council

Country Parks Trading Officer

Northumberland County Council
£21,589 - £23,836
Countryside Parks Trading Officer Country Parks including Druridge Bay
Recuriter: Northumberland County Council

Support Office (Back Office Systems)

North West Leicestershire District Council
Band E, £25,295- £28,785
An opportunity to develop and manage back office systems for Environmental Protection, Development Control, Environmental Health and Building Control. Coalville, Leicestershire
Recuriter: North West Leicestershire District Council

Head of Environmental Services

City of York Council
Grade 12 Level 1- 4 £49,275 to £59,079 (basic pay plus a supplement up to £59,079)
Want to Live and Work in the Best City? York, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: City of York Council

Operational Manager - 2 Jobs

Kirklees Metropolitan Council
£48,172 - £49,047
This role is based within The Environment Service within the Directorate of Economy and Infrastructure. Kirklees, West Yorkshire
Recuriter: Kirklees Metropolitan Council

Relief Minibus Driver

North Yorkshire County Council
We are looking for a caring, flexible and committed person to help us provide this transport. Harrogate, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: North Yorkshire County Council

Principal Transport Officer (Policy)

St. Helens Metropolitan Borough Council
£38,813 To £40,760 per annum
This is an exciting opportunity for an energetic and motivated individual to drive forward transport policy to... St Helens, Merseyside
Recuriter: St. Helens Metropolitan Borough Council

Traffic Management Leader

City of York Council
£35,500 to £40,710 per annum
City of York Council have an exciting opportunity for an experienced transport professional to lead our Traffic Team. York, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: City of York Council

Traffic Project Officer

City of York Council
£26,875 to £29,783 per annum
City of York Council have a great opportunity for a Projects Officer to join our busy Traffic Team. York, North Yorkshire
Recuriter: City of York Council