Is the Tyne and Wear QCS Board’s opinion a catalyst for change?

 

Earlier this month, the Tyne and Wear QCS Board published its long-awaited opinion on North East Combined Authority (NECA)’s proposed Quality Contract Scheme.

The verdict? In an opinion which has been welcomed by the region’s bus operators, the board found that the scheme failed to meet certain statutory public interest tests and recommended that it should not be implemented.

But to what extent is NECA bound by the board’s opinion? Could Nexus (NECA’s transport executive) safely disregard the opinion and proceed with the scheme regardless?

”Local

One answer to that question is found in the make-up of the board itself. It’s a statutory body whose role is to give an opinion, not a tribunal charged with making a decision.

The legal status of the board’s opinion was hotly debated in the hearing. The conclusion reached by the board was that it has a remit to consider and reach independent conclusions based on the evidence placed before it, but, importantly, that its opinion is not a judgment and is not, of itself, binding.

Nevertheless, whilst NECA is not technically bound by the opinion, it is highly improbable that it would simply ignore it and successfully press ahead with the scheme - and indeed Nexus has already said that this won’t happen.

After all, any decision by Nexus that sought to disregard the clear and well-reasoned views of the board would be susceptible to judicial review, and any operator seeking to challenge the decision to implement the scheme would have ample evidence to support a claim that the decision was substantively flawed.

The publicity that the opinion has generated will also doubtless encourage operators to challenge any attempts to reintroduce the scheme in the future.

But how will other local authorities in other regions react? They could take the view that any QCS is dependent on its own facts, diluting the impact of the board’s opinion in this case. That feels risky. Or they could treat the opinion as part of the direction of travel towards devolution and bus franchising.

So where does all this leave the future of the bus industry? Nexus’ slow and ultimately fruitless journey from its initial proposal to this decision has demonstrated that the current regulatory process may not be fit for purpose; new forms of partnership between operators and local authorities now seem more likely than ever.

New regulatory structures should be informed by the board’s description of the lessons to be learned from the Tyne & Wear QCS, which set out recommendations for any future franchising proposals in any form. These include that such proposals should follow a staged, independently scrutinised approach and that the legislative framework should specifically address the issue of how any adverse effects on operators stack up against the benefits.

In practical terms, that means thinking about compensation if and when franchising is introduced.

The board has set out a very helpful set of signposts for the industry, and both of these specific recommendations have been welcomed by operators. However, there remains an obvious tension between the Government’s Northern Powerhouse plans to devolve more control over local transport to local authorities on the one hand, and the need to safeguard operators’ interests on the other.

So the Department for Transport has some thinking to do about how and to what extent it will propose to compensate any affected operators in the brave new world to come.

As a new regulatory structure develops, the industry will also need to take into account operational risks including those raised by the board in its opinion including, perhaps most importantly, the impact of local authorities taking on revenue risk.

Any failure to properly assess and understand that risk in particular might lead to potentially severe consequences, both economic and political.

Richard Collins is from national law firm Bond Dickinson LLP

 

Also see

 
comments powered by Disqus
 
 
highways jobs

Commercial Projects Manager

Wirral Borough Council
£38,813 - £41,675)
In this role, you’ll help to develop the Council’s internal highway design traded service Wirral, Merseyside
Recuriter: Wirral Borough Council

Parking Strategy Project Manager

Tile Hill
£500 - £700 per day
A Parking Strategy Project Manager is required by our local authority client to lead an important workstream of a major urban regeneration programme. London
Recuriter: Tile Hill

Assistant Director – Business Infrastructure

Surrey County Council
Up to £98,000 per annum
Our Assistant Director - Business Infrastructure is charged with transforming the way Surrey County Council operates through... Kingston Upon Thames (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recuriter: Surrey County Council

Assistant Director – Project Delivery

Surrey County Council
Up to £98,000 per annum
This is a unique point in time for Surrey County Council. You will be joining our new Land and Property team at... Kingston Upon Thames (City/Town), London (Greater)
Recuriter: Surrey County Council

Environmental Health Officer/Technical Officer

Royal Borough of Greenwich
£31.548 - £39.774
You will ideally hold or be working towards a BSc or Master’s degree in Environmental Health and be... Greenwich, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Royal Borough of Greenwich

Highways Officer

Lincolnshire County Council
£25,295 - £27,905
This position is critical in delivering the Local Highways Management services in accordance with the Highways Act 1980 and the... Lincolnshire
Recuriter: Lincolnshire County Council

Senior Transport Planner (Parking Policy and Projects)

Camden London Borough Council
£36,630 - £42,490
You’ll provide professional and technical advice on a range of areas that fall within the remit of the service in line with the... Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Project and Programme Manager 

Great Yarmouth Borough Council
up to £54,642
For this role, it is the pride you take in achieving ambitious goals at pace that will set you apart. Great Yarmouth, Norfolk
Recuriter: Great Yarmouth Borough Council

Health and Safety Principal Environmnetal Health Officer

Camden London Borough Council
£40,829 - £47,360 per annum
We are seeking for a highly motivated and experienced Principal Environmental Health Officer to join our busy Health and Safety Team. Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Senior Civil Engineers

Transport Scotland
£37,418 –  £45,241
These are exciting and challenging roles! Scotland
Recuriter: Transport Scotland

Environmental Health Officer

Camden London Borough Council
Competitive Salary
The ideal candidate will have a detailed knowledge /understanding of the Housing Act 2004, and other legislation that... Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Assistant Engineer or Engineer

London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth
£25,327 - £36,036 depending on skills
We have an exciting opportunity for a permanent Assistant Engineer/Engineer within the traffic and engineering division to... London (Greater)
Recuriter: London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth

Head of Infrastructure, Sustainability & Transport

The Royal Borough of Windsor & Maidenhead
Up to £93k
This is a new role that will focus on the development of a cohesive transport and infrastructure strategy for the borough... Windsor, Berkshire
Recuriter: The Royal Borough of Windsor & Maidenhead

Senior Engineer

London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth
£35,246 - £45,704 depending on skills
Are you an experienced traffic or highway engineer with a good track record in the delivery of traffic, public realm and/or parking schemes? London (Greater)
Recuriter: London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth

Senior Traffic Orders Officer

London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth
£35,246 - £42,710 depending on skills
Do you have experience of working for a local authority processing and delivering traffic management orders? London (Greater)
Recuriter: London Borough of Richmond upon Thames and London Borough of Wandsworth

Roadworks Inspector

Transport for London
£32,500 plus substantial benefits
You’ll review thousands of roadworks reports sent by other operational TfL staff and the Met Police andñ... Southwark, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Transport for London

Transportation Engineer

Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council
£29,636 - £33,799 per annum
Applicants should hold an appropriate qualification, preferably to degree level, and have knowledge of transportation issues. Sandwell, West Midlands
Recuriter: Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council

Trading Standards Officer

Camden London Borough Council
£36,630 - £42,490 per annum
Seeking to recruit highly motivated and experienced Trading Standards Officer’s to join our busy Business and Consumer Services team. Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Nature Conservation Officer

Camden London Borough Council
£36,630 - £42,490
Exciting opportunity now exists for a dynamic nature conservation professional, to be the lead officer for the Council in all matters relating to Camden, London (Greater)
Recuriter: Camden London Borough Council

Air Quality Monitoring Project Manager

Birmingham City Council
£34,788 - £42,683
Seeking a skilled and dedicated individual with a background in environmental protection and air quality to... Birmingham, West Midlands
Recuriter: Birmingham City Council